In the Large Truck Crash Causation Study (LTCCS), a federal study that sent investigators to a national sample of serious truck crashes, fatigue was present for 13.0% of the large trucks involved in fatal and injury crashes. Trucks coded with a fatigued driver were 8.0 times as likely as other trucks to be assigned the crash’s critical reason.1,2 The study covered crashes from April 2001 to December 2003.

Texas has no truck-only fatigue count in its published tables. The Texas Department of Transportation (TxDOT) recorded “fatigued or asleep” as a contributing factor in 8,163 crashes in 2025, 98 of them fatal, but that figure covers drivers of every kind of vehicle.3

How often fatigue appears in truck crashes

The LTCCS was run by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). For each crash in its sample, a researcher and a state truck inspector went to the scene, interviewed drivers and witnesses, inspected the truck and reviewed the driver’s logbook.2 Investigators coded hundreds of possible “associated factors” for each vehicle. Several relate to fatigue.

LTCCS measure Share of large trucks Relative risk
Fatigue present 13.0% 8.0
Driver under work-related pressure 9.2% 4.7
Driver pressured to operate even though fatigued 3.2% Not reported
Illness 2.8% 34.0
Driver non-performance (asleep, heart attack or seizure, other impairment) as the critical reason 11.6% of trucks assigned a critical reason Not applicable

Shares come from FMCSA’s 2006 Report to Congress, which estimates that about 18,000 of roughly 141,000 trucks in fatal and injury crashes during the study period had a fatigued driver.1 Relative risk comes from FMCSA’s 2007 Analysis Brief, which rounds the work-pressure share to 10% and labels it “felt under work pressure from carrier.”2

Fatigue ranked 10th among the factors most often coded for trucks. Of the 19 factors with a statistically meaningful link to the critical reason, FMCSA grouped fatigue with illness and drug use as conditions of the driver before the crash, as opposed to driving mistakes such as speeding or following too closely.2 For the full ranking, see the leading causes of commercial truck crashes.

Truck drivers versus car drivers

In crashes between one large truck and one passenger vehicle, investigators coded fatigue twice as often for the car, van, pickup or SUV driver as for the truck driver: 14.7% of passenger vehicle drivers against 7.5% of truck drivers.1 The pattern ran the other way for speed. Truck drivers were coded as driving too fast for conditions more often than the passenger vehicle drivers in those crashes.1

Why newer counts look so different

Three federal figures on fatigue are in circulation, and they measure different things.

  • 13.0% of large trucks in fatal and injury crashes in 2001-2003 had fatigue present, from on-scene LTCCS investigations.1
  • 1.2% of large-truck drivers in fatal crashes in 2022 (71 of 5,758) had “asleep or fatigued” recorded as an impairment factor in NHTSA’s Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS), as tabulated by FMCSA. The share was 1.4% in 2020 and 1.2% in 2021.4
  • “Over 30 percent” is FMCSA’s own wording in its October 2026 pilot program notices, which say previous research shows fatigue “may be involved in over 30 percent of fatal CMV crashes.” The notices do not name the research behind that figure.5,6

FARS is a census of fatal crashes nationwide, and it contains information only on fatal crashes.4 The LTCCS was a sample that sent investigators to each crash and covered injury crashes as well as fatal ones.2 Texas Mobility Outlook found no source that reconciles the three figures, so this page reports each with its method rather than choosing one.

In the FARS data, the fatigue factor was more common in single-vehicle crashes: 32 of 1,111 large-truck drivers in single-vehicle fatal crashes in 2022 (2.9%), against 39 of 4,647 in multiple-vehicle crashes (0.8%).4

Fatigue in Texas crash data

TxDOT’s 2025 contributing-factor table lists “fatigued or asleep” for 8,163 crashes statewide, including 98 fatal crashes.3 By Texas Mobility Outlook’s calculation, that is 1.5% of the 538,860 reportable crashes and 2.8% of the 3,476 fatal crashes TxDOT recorded in 2025.7

Those numbers cannot be read as truck figures. TxDOT counts a crash under a factor when an officer reports that factor for any driver involved, and the published table does not split drivers by vehicle type.3 Officers can also list several factors per crash, so the factors overlap. For how TxDOT’s statewide death toll has moved, see Texas traffic fatalities.

The published county totals for crashes involving commercial vehicles, without factor detail, are on the Houston truck crash statistics page.

How the rules try to limit fatigue

Hours-of-service limits are the federal rules aimed most directly at fatigue. FMCSA’s 2026 notices describe addressing driver fatigue as “at the heart of HOS regulations,” which cap driving within a 24-hour period and across a 7- or 8-day window.5 Interstate drivers of property-carrying trucks get 11 hours of driving within a 14-hour window after 10 hours off, with a 30-minute break after 8 hours of driving.8 The hours-of-service rules page covers the limits, exceptions and Texas intrastate rules in full.

Since Dec. 18, 2017, most carriers that must keep records of duty status have had to use electronic logging devices instead of paper logs.9,10 Enforcement still finds problems. In the 2025 International Roadcheck run by the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance (CVSA), hours-of-service violations were 32.4% of driver out-of-service violations in Canada and the U.S., and false logs another 10.0%.11 CVSA said falsified logs conceal how long a driver has actually been driving or on duty.11

What the 2025 pilot programs would test

FMCSA has proposed two pilot studies that would give about 256 drivers each more flexibility in scheduling rest.12,13

  • The split duty period pilot would let drivers pause the 14-hour window for 30 minutes to 3 hours at a pickup or delivery location.12 FMCSA proposed a similar pause in 2019 but left it out of the 2020 final rule after commenters warned that carriers, shippers or receivers could pressure drivers to use the pause for reasons other than rest. The agency also cited long “detention time” waiting to load or unload as a reason for the new study.5
  • The flexible sleeper berth pilot would cut the longer of the two sleeper periods from 7 hours to as little as 5, allowing “5/5” or “6/4” splits.13 FMCSA’s notice summarizes earlier research as finding that split sleep can be restorative and that the body’s daily rhythm affects fatigue more than splitting sleep does.6

Both studies would compare the same drivers working under current rules and under the exemption, over 16 weeks each. Data would come from surveys before and after, psychomotor vigilance tests, self-rated sleepiness, a wrist-worn activity monitor, records of duty status and a telematics device in the truck.5,6 The Virginia Tech Transportation Institute would collect the records of duty status.5

Only carriers meeting safety criteria could join. They could not be rated “Unsatisfactory,” have FMCSA enforcement actions in the past 3 years, or have driver or vehicle out-of-service rates above the national average. Drivers listed in FMCSA’s Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse would be excluded.5 As of Oct. 7, 2026, the data collection still needed federal approval, with public comments due Dec. 7, 2026.5,6

Limits of the fatigue data

  • The LTCCS is old. Its crashes date from 2001-2003, before the electronic logging mandate and the 2020 hours-of-service rule.2
  • Two LTCCS documents disagree slightly on the sample: 967 crashes in the 2006 Report to Congress and 963 in the 2007 Analysis Brief. This page uses the Report’s percentages and the Brief’s relative risk values.1,2
  • Methods differ. FARS records factors for fatal crashes only, while the LTCCS coded factors after detailed investigations of fatal and injury crashes. Texas Mobility Outlook has not found a study that measures how much of the gap between 1.2% and 13.0% comes from method.
  • Texas factors cover all drivers. TxDOT’s fatigue count includes cars, pickups and motorcycles as well as trucks.3

Fatigue is one of several driver conditions in the crash research. Equipment problems are covered in commercial truck maintenance failures.

Sources

Figures were read from the documents below and checked by Texas Mobility Outlook. Links go to the original publisher. Accessed October 2026 unless noted.

  1. FMCSA, Report to Congress on the Large Truck Crash Causation Study, March 2006.
  2. FMCSA Office of Research and Analysis, The Large Truck Crash Causation Study: Analysis Brief (FMCSA-RRA-07-017), July 2007.
  3. TxDOT, Crash Contributing Factors, 2025. Statewide section. A crash can carry more than one factor.
  4. FMCSA Crash Data Analytics Division, Large Truck and Bus Crash Facts 2022, September 2025.
  5. FMCSA, Federal Register, Agency Information Collection Activities; Hours of Service of Drivers (Split Duty Period pilot, 91 FR 63640), October 6, 2026.
  6. FMCSA, Federal Register, Agency Information Collection Activities; Hours of Service of Drivers (Flexible Sleeper Berth pilot, 91 FR 64214), October 7, 2026.
  7. TxDOT, Rural and Urban Crashes and Injuries by Severity, 2015-2025 (table 11). STATEWIDE row used for total reportable crashes and fatal crashes. 2015-2024 editions at crash-records/{year}/11.pdf.
  8. eCFR, 49 CFR 395.3, Maximum driving time for property-carrying vehicles. Last amended 85 FR 33452, June 1, 2020.
  9. eCFR, 49 CFR 395.8, Driver's record of duty status.
  10. FMCSA, Federal Register, Electronic Logging Devices and Hours of Service Supporting Documents (80 FR 78292), December 16, 2015.
  11. CVSA, CVSA Releases 2025 International Roadcheck Results, October 7, 2025.
  12. FMCSA, Federal Register, Pilot Program To Allow Commercial Drivers To Pause Their 14-Hour Driving Window (90 FR 44872), September 17, 2025.
  13. FMCSA, Federal Register, Pilot Program To Allow Commercial Drivers To Split Sleeper Berth Time (90 FR 44790), September 17, 2025.
Texas Mobility Outlook Editorial. Unsigned reporting, data pages and research notes are published under the Texas Mobility Outlook Editorial byline. Figures are compiled from public sources listed on each page and checked against the original documents before publication. Questions about a figure can be sent through the corrections page.